cover photo, source: getty images

M.S. Computational Design Practices, Colloquium II

by: Kevin Liberman, Fall 2023

Introduction

We are living in exciting times: architecture and computation have become more accessible and widely applied than ever before, extending their reach to an endless array of fields, including climate and environmental health.

Technology affords us the ability to look beyond the limits of our senses at other spatial and temporal scales, it can therefore play a key role in prompting us as a species to better understand the ecological systems that we are a part of and how they can be utilized to improve our climate response, and by consequence, our environmental health.

Garden City vision

The vision of the Garden City in early 20th century England

WELL standard

WELL Rating system by the International WELL Building Institute launched in 2014

Although designing for health is not a new concept, the term healthy architecture has emerged in recent years as a response to a growing epistemology and application of architectural practices employed to improve public health outcomes.

Then came the global pandemic and this year’s wildfire season. These two phenomena, brought us to a new collective consciousness, where we all realized that our spaces, just as much as our behaviors, create an immediate and massive effect on our personal health and safety.

Masking during the pandemic

Masking in public during the Covid-19 Pandemic

Wildfire Smoke in NYC

Canadian wildfire smoke engulfing NYC, June 2023

While there are many factors in healthy architecture to study, I’m going to focus on indoor air quality. The truth is that both indoor and outdoor air pollution, combined, is the third leading cause of death around the world and for a species that spends 90% of its time inside of a building, how well do we actually know our indoor air quality or attempt to change it?

To learn more about indooor air pollution, such as common pollutants and sources, visit: EPA's Report on the Environment

Global deaths by risk factor

Precedents

There have been numerous experiments, both architectural and within the context of technology / HCI, that look at air quality.

Dustmarks by Offenhuber

Staubmarke (dustmark) by Dietmar Offenhuber
Stuttgart, Germany 2018

Yellow Dust

C+arquitectos/In The Air (Nerea Calvillo with Raúl Nieves, Pep Tornabell, Yee Thong Chai, Emma Garnett, Marina Fernandez)

Smog-Free Tower by Studio Roosegaarde

Smog-Free Tower by Studio Roosegaarde;
the world's first smog vacuum cleaner

My question is: are there alternate ways to improve air quality using natural building materials?

Use of Biomaterials + Architectural Microbiome

There has been a lot of advancement in the use of biomaterials for architecture. In particular, mycelium composites have been recognized for their ability to be grown and composted anywhere and sequester carbon. Mycelium composites in architecture have been looked at mainly as a low-carbon alternative for thermal insulation and acoustic insulation.

Hy-Fi is composed of bricks grown organically from mycelium and shredded corn stalks, the bricks were later composted.

HyFi Pavillion

A housing facade, fiberglass with a mycelium core will be used in an Oakland, California affordable housing project by the studio The Living.

Oakland Housing Facade

Alive, a pavilion for the Venice Biennale by The Living is made out of dried fibres of luffa – an inexpensive, renewable and fast-growing vegetable that grows on vines in tropical and subtropical regions. It is speculated that the pavilion can serve as a "probiotic" scaffolding for the microbiome of the space.

Alive Pavilion

Mogu is an Italian startup that makes mycelium-composite acoustic panels for wall covering.

Mogu Mycelium acoustic panels

Mycelium composites have already been used as a thermal insulation alternative because the two materials have similar structural qualities, thermal capacity, density and porosity, as evidenced in a side-by-side comparison of their electron microscope images.

Mycelium composite SEM image
Glass Wool SEM image

Proposal

Research Question: Can mycelium composites be effective at filtering indoor air pollutants?

How can we tell? Can we sense and visualize air quality in real time?

By extension, mycelium composites can have similar structural qualities to man-made air filters. In addition, an emerging field of research is myco-remediation and myco-filtration, using fungi to clean up heavily contaminated water and soil. There has been specific research published that suggests mycelium-composite panels are effective at outdoor particulate matter adsorption.

SEM image of a face mask

SEM images of a surgical mask

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rinma.2021.100208

Experimental Setup

A design-build-test- and -sense system for mycelium-composite wall panels & sensing indoor air quality

System Diagram

Building Phase

  • Either mycelium grown from scratch using online recipes such as from the Materiom database or from pre-inoculated substrate from Ecovative
  • Test different substrates (if feasible), densities, and additives.
  • CNC-mill molds to apply different textures, can be modelled parametrically using data informed by the IAQ sensors
Building Phase

Sensing Phase [In Progress]

  • Connect indoor air quality sensors (either DIY, commercial, or hybrid)
  • Using OpenAQ data schema, stream data to web application
  • Visualize the present and historical readings

Exploring non-visual user interactions using a commercial indoor air sensor (Airthings Wave)

Prototype user interface streaming data from an outdoor sensor:

Testing Environment

  • Prototype testing begins with small air chamber, if the results are meaningful testing may change scale later on
  • Test panels are tested against an alternative and control
  • Alternative could be another bio-based material, in particular, cellulose based such as wood, hemp, flax etc.
  • Control is conventional dry-wall
Testing Phase

Possible Extensions

Lastly, a possible future extension of this work could be making the mycelium itself, at least a live section of it, be the sensor. This is inspired by computational research compiled into a book called Fungal Machines. The research shows it's possible to measure pressure, humidity, and other variables. If reliable, the mycelium would act as both sensor and actuator, creating a living architecture that could tell us directly how it’s interacting with the space instead of having to infer it from external conditions.

Mining logical circuits in fungi, published in Nature: Scientific Reports, 2022

References

  1. ourworldindata.org/indoor-air-pollution
  2. archdaily.com/521266/hy-fi-the-organic-mushroom-brick-tower
  3. reasonstobecheerful.world/for-more-sustainable-affordable-housing-just-add-mushrooms
  4. dezeen.com/2021/10/23/the-living-probiotic-architectural-alive-pavilion-venice-biennale
  5. openaq.org
  6. mdpi.com/2073-4360/14/22/4926
  7. nature.com/articles/s41598-022-22102-6
  8. sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2590048X21000418
  9. brunel.ac.uk/news-and-events/news/articles/Mushrooms-work-magic-on-air-pollution
  10. sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950061823036590
  11. Karana, Elvin & Blauwhoff, Davine & Hultink, Erik-Jan & Camere, Serena. (2018). When the material grows: A case study on designing (with) mycelium-based materials. International Journal of Design. 12. 119-136.
  12. offenhuber.net/project/staubmarke-dustmark